White woman claims she was fired for reporting spanking wins $200K
Chicago Sun-Times, March 10, 2009
BY MARY MITCHELL Sun-Times Columnist
Fewer topics are as culturally divisive as spankings. If you are black, you probably call the act of disciplining a child with corporal punishment "a whupping."
While all blacks don't beat their children, and all whites don't view spankings as abuse, we do seem to be divided.
When the race of the person observing the spanking is white and the child getting whipped is black, it becomes even more complicated.
For instance, a federal court jury recently awarded a white woman $200,000 in a discrimination case that involved "a bathroom whupping" of a 6-year-old African-American child.
In 2006, Cathleen Schandelmeier-Bartels was working as a cultural program coordinator at the South Shore Cultural Center, a Chicago Park District facility. Schandelmeier-Bartels alleged in the lawsuit that she was fired because she reported to the Illinois Department of Children and Family Service and the police that the 6-year-old's aunt beat him in the park district bathroom.
A federal jury agreed.
"I feel sad that the public has to pay for someone's mistake," Schandelmeier-Bartels said during a telephone interview.
Schandelmeier-Bartels claimed that after she complained, an African-American program coordinator told her "It's a black thing: We beat our children."
Later, when she took the matter to Andrea Adams, her supervisor, she was again told: "This is how we discipline our children in our culture."
She now feels vindicated.
"In my mind, this is the primary message: It is not a cultural prerogative to beat our children," Schandelmeier-Bartels said in a message she sent posted on her Facebook page. No hitting 'no matter what,' she says
The Chicago Park District maintains that Schandelmeier-Bartels was not discriminated against. "Our position is that [she] was fired for lack of administrative ability to run the summer camp," a spokesman said.
The agency has not yet decided whether to appeal the jury verdict, and Schandelmeier-Bartels also has a suit pending in state court.
When it comes to abuse, Schandelmeier-Bartels is probably more sensitive than most. She has worked with the International Society for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, and in 1996, she coordinated a video for the organization that got global attention. "I don't believe in ever spanking or hitting a child no matter what," she told me. "If someone else other than me had been outside that bathroom that day, I doubt that the incident would have been reported."
She's probably right. 'Whack' 'Ow' 'Whack' 'Ow' 'Whack' 'Ow'
For those of you who don't know, a "bathroom whupping" usually happens after a child has acted out repeatedly in school or in public. In this case, the 6-year-old boy had gotten five write-ups for bad behavior during the summer program. A phone call was made to his mother, and his aunt picked him up.
The aunt asked Schandelmeier-Bartels "where the bathroom was."
When she returned to where she left the boy and his aunt, Schandelmeier-Bartels said she heard "Whack" "Ow" "Whack" "Ow" "Whack" "Ow" several times, according to the suit. She reported what she considered abuse to the state and the police.
The next day, the boy's aunt complained to Andrea Adams, the supervisor at the cultural center.
Schandelmeier-Bartels said her supervisor "yelled at" her, and told her to get out of her sight.
"Just because you don't beat your child doesn't mean she can't beat hers," Schandelmeier-Bartels said she was told. "Who are you to tell her how to raise her child?"
Obviously, spanking is not a "black thing," although it is perceived as such by many. Despite the ongoing debate, spanking is still viewed as an acceptable way to discipline unruly children by a lot of people.
There also is a difference between physically disciplining a child and abusing one.
Still, I can understand why Schandelmeier-Bartels, who is an advocate against physical discipline, did what she did.
But the Chicago Park District employees involved in this incident were the people who acted irresponsibly.
When a 6-year-old boy misbehaves to the point that he is about to be suspended from a summer program, he could be crying out for help. Unfortunately, Chicago Park District employees may have missed that because they couldn't see beyond Schandelmeier-Bartels' race.
March 10, 2009
Thank you, Mary, for noting that the boy who was hit was crying out for help. As we know, violence and corporal punishment do nothing to address the help that was needed. In fact, it heaps insult upon injury or perhaps in this case, injury upon injury.
In this world, violence is easy and corporal punishment of children perhaps the easiest act of all. Yet, the research is clear: violence negatively impacts brain, hurts the victims, damages families, is related to mental illness, crime, substance abuse and reinforces more violence. What's not to get? Perhaps, this information along with positive parenting should become widely taught in schools so that peace and non-violence can grow to be as widely accepted as the violent messages and acts with which we are flooded from the media to the streets to our homes. In the meanwhile, we need more people like Cathleen Schandelmeier-Bartels who are willing to risk speaking out against all forms of violence. I know I will continue to do so. You never know what seed you might be planting for a more positive and peaceful world: a world where even children have an equal right to protection from all forms of violence and can get the help they need.
Dr. M. Y. Gómez
Some folks insist that the old razor strop hanging from a nail in the broom closet brings back fond childhood memories. They should think again. Truth is, it's long overdue for a proper burial -- right next to the slave auction block and the Klansman's noose.
Jordan Riak, Exec. Dir., PTAVE
News8 - February 9, 2009 - Present
News7 - August 10, 2007 - February 9, 2009
News6 - August 21, 2006 - July 23, 2007
News5 - January 3, 2005 - April 18, 2006
News4 - November 6, 2002 - December 26, 2004
News3 - July 7, 2099 - October 26, 2002
News2 - May. 1, 1998 - June 27, 1999
News1 - April 27, 1976 - April 30, 1998