PTAVE's letter to state board of education members and others in states that allow corporal punishment in schools, and their responses
June 4 - July 15, 2009

This letter was sent snail-mail on PTAVE stationery and addressed individually.


Dear _____________:

When a school's policy permitting corporal punishment is challenged, punishers and their defenders typically point out that the practice is legal, that those who physically punish students are following established guidelines, and that the action is carried out in the presence of a witness.

I'm curious to know if any school of education teaches undergraduates the correct method for hitting a child's pelvic area with a wooden board. Surely, if there were an established "right method," then teachers' colleges would include it in their curriculum. As a general rule, professionals who engage in potentially dangerous contact with a subject's body are trained and tested in the procedure, and are certified. Educators who strike students seem to be the only exception. If I'm wrong - if there is a degree-granting institution in your state that offers training in how to hit children - please let me know.

As for presence of a witnesses during the event, I have been unable to find anyone to explain exactly what the witness is supposed to be preventing. What criteria apply? Is the mere presence of a witness enough to keep a paddler from crossing some mysterious, unspoken boundary? Can you cite one example of a witness who did something? If the witness happens to be a voyeur, and is colluding with the paddler in an act of sexual sadism, then what? Such things do happen, as a visit to www.nospank.net/101.htm will confirm.

Any light you can shed on these matters would be much appreciated. I look forward to your response.

Jordan Riak, Exec. Dir.
PTAVE
P.O. Box 1033, Alamo, CA 94507


RECIPIENTS OF THE ABOVE LETTER
Replies are posted immediately upon receipt.

ALABAMA (Sent to the below-listed AL recipients on June 4, 2009)
Dr. Joseph B. Morton, State Superintendent of Education
Dr. Eddie R. Johnson, Deputy State Superintendent of Education - REPLY
Dr. Tommy Bice, Deputy State Superintendent of Education
Feagin Johnson Jr., Assistant State Superintendent of Education
Craig Pouncey, Assistant State Superintendent of Education, Division of Administrative and Financial Services
Sherrill Parris, Assistant State Superintendent of Education - REPLY

ARIZONA (Sent to the below-listed AZ recipients on June 9, 2009)
Tom Horne, Superintendent Tom Horne
Dr. Vicki Balentine, Member, Board of Education
Jacob Moore, Member, Board of Education
Jesse Ary, Member, Board of Education
Dr. John Haeger, Member, Board of Education
Jaime Molera, Member, Board of Education
Bonnie Kasey, Member, Board of Education
Larry Lucero, Member, Board of Education
Anita Mendoza, Member, Board of Education
Dr. Karen Nicodemus, Member, Board of Education
Cecilia Owen, Member, Board of Education
Vance Yanez, Executive Director, Board of Education

ARKANSAS (Sent to the below-listed AR recipients on June 15, 2009)
Randy Lawson, Chair, Board of Education
Dr. Naccaman Williams, Vice Chair, Board of Education
Sherry Burrow, Member, Board of Education
Jim Cooper, Member, Board of Education
Brenda Gullett, Member, Board of Education
Samuel Ledbetter, Member, Board of Education
Alice Williams Mahony, Member, Board of Education
Dr. Ben Mays, Member, Board of Education
Diane Tatum, Member, Board of Education
Diana Julian, Ed.D., Interim Arkansas Education Commissioner

COLORADO (Sent to the below-listed CO recipients on June 22, 2009)
Bob Schaffer, Chairman, Board of Education
Randy DeHoff , Vice-Chairman, State Board of Education
Elaine Gantz Berman, Member, State Board of Education
Jane Goff, Member, State Board of Education
Peggy Littleton, Member, State Board of Education
Marcia Neal, Member, State Board of Education
Angelika Schroeder, Member, State Board of Education
Dwight Jones, Colorado Commissioner of Education
Mary Frances Nevans, Director of State Board Relations

FLORIDA (Sent to the below-listed FL recipients on June 27, 2009)
T. Willard Fair, Chairman, State Board of Education
Peter Boulware, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. Akshay Desai, Member, State Board of Education
Roberto Martinez, Member, State Board of Education
John R. Padget, Member, State Board of Education
Kathleen Shanahan, Member, State Board of Education
Linda Taylor, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. Eric J. Smith, Florida Department of Education, Commissioner - REPLY

GEORGIA (Sent to the below-listed GA recipients on June 29, 2009)
Kathy Cox, State Superintendent of Schools - REPLY
Stephen Pruitt, Chief of Staff, State Department of Education
Linda M. Zechmann, Member, State Board of Education
Elizabeth J. Ragsdale, Member, State Board of Education
William Bradley Bryant, Member, State Board of Education
James E. Bostic, Jr., Member, State Board of Education
Robert "Buzz" Law, Member, State Board of Education
Jose R. Perez, Member, State Board of Education
Wanda Barrs, Member, State Board of Education
Larry E. Winter, Member, State Board of Education
Brian K. Burdette, Member, State Board of Education
Albert "Al" Hodge, Member, State Board of Education
Allen C. Rice, Member, State Board of Education
Mary Sue Murray, Member, State Board of Education

IDAHO (Sent to the below-listed ID recipients on June 29, 2009)
Tom Luna, State Superintendent of Education
Marybeth Flachbart, Deputy Superintendent
Milford Terrell, Member, State Board of Education
Paul Agidius, President, State Board of Education
Richard Westerberg, Vice President, State Board of Education
Kenneth Edmunds, Secretary, State Board of Education
Rod Lewis, Member State Board of Education
Don Soltman, Member State Board of Education
Mike Rush, Executive Director, State Board of Education
June Boucher, Executive Assistant, State Board of Education
Tracie Bent, Planning, Policy & HR Officer, State Board of Education
Tamara Baysinger, Charter Commissioner, Prograom Mgr., State Board of Education
Aylee Schaefer, Blind/Visually Impaired & Deaf/Hare of Hearling Services TRansition Coord., State Board of Education
Selna Grace, Research Analyst/Grant Developer, State Board of Education

INDIANA (Sent to the below-listed IN recipients on July 1, 2009)
Dr. Tony Bennett, Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction
Dr. Gwendolyn Adell, Member, State Board of Education
Jo Blacketor, Member, State Board of Education
Stephen Gabet, Member, State Board of Education
Sarah M. O’Brien, Member, State Board of Education
Neil Pickett, Member, State Board of Education
Michael Pettibone, Member, State Board of Education
Daniel J. Elsener, Member, State Board of Education
Vicki Snyder, Member, State Board of Education
James D. Edwards, Member, State Board of Education
David Shane, Member, State Board of Education
Jeffery P. Zaring, State Board Administrator

KANSAS (Sent to the below-listed KS recipients on July 2, 2009)
Janet Waugh, Chair, State Board of Education
Sue Storm, Member, State Board of Education
John W. Bacon, Member, State Board of Education
Carolyn L. Wims-Campbell, Member, State Board of Education
Sally Cauble, Member, State Board of Education
Kathy Martin, Member, State Board of Education
Kenneth Willard, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. Walt Chappell, Member, State Board of Education
Jana Shaver, Vice Chair, State Board of Education
David T. Dennis, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. Alexa Posny, Kansas Commissioner of Education

KENTUCKY (Sent to the below-listed KY recipients on July 3, 2009)
Kevin Noland, Interim Commissioner, KY Dept. of Education - REPLY
C.B. Akins, Member, State Board of Education
Kaye Baird, Member, State Board of Education
Joe Brothers, Member, State Board of Education
Dorothy Z. Combs, Member, State Board of Education - REPLY
Jeanne Huber Ferguson, Member, State Board of Education
Judy Gibbons, Member, State Board of Education
Billy Harper, Member, State Board of Education
Doug Hubbard, Member, State Board of Education
David K. Karem, Member, State Board of Education
Austin W. Moss, Member, State Board of Education
Brigitte B. Ramsey, Member, State Board of Education
Robert L. King, President CPE (Ex Officio), Council on Postsecondary Education, Member, State Board of Education

LOUISIANA (Sent to the below-listed LA recipients on June 5, 2009)
Paul G. Pastorek, Superintendent, Department of Education
Dale Bayard, 7th BESE District
John L. Bennett, Member-at-Large
Glenny Lee Buquet, 3rd BESE
Penny Dastugue, Member-at-Large
James D. Garvey, Jr., 1st BESE District
Louella Givens, 2nd BESE District/Secretary-Treasurer
Keith Guice, 5th BESE District/President
Linda Johnson, 8th BESE District
Walter Lee, 4th BESE District/Vice-President
Tammie A. McDaniel, Member-at-Large
Chas Roemer, 6th BESE District

House Education Committee Members
James K. Armes
Elton M. Aubert
Austin Baden
Thomas Carmody
Stephen F. Carter
Billy R. Chandler
Charles R. Chaney
Herbert B. Dixon - REPLY
Hollis Downs
John Bel Edwards
Rickey Hardy
Frank A. Hoffman
Walt Leger, III
Clifton R. Richardson
Harold L. Ritchie
Patricia Haynes Smith
Major Thibaut

MISSISSIPPI (Sent to the below-listed MS recipients on July 5, 2009)
John W. Jordan, Ed.D., Interim State Superintendent of Education - REPLY
William Harold Jones, Chair, State Board of Education
Charles McClelland, Vice-Chair, State Board of Education
Sondra Parker Caillavet, Member, State Board of Education
Howell "Hal" N. Gage, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. O. Wayne Gann, Member, State Board of Education
Claude Hartley, Member, State Board of Education
Martha "Jackie" Murphy, Member, State Board of Education
Rosetta Richard, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. David Sistrunk, Member, State Board of Education
Dr. Hank M. Bounds, Executive Secretary, State Board of Education

MISSOURI (Sent to the below-listed MO recipients on July 6, 2009)
Russell V. Thompson, Member, State Board of Education
Sybl Slaughter, Member, State Board of Education
J. Michael Ponder, Member, State Board of Education
Deborah L. Demien, Member, State Board of Education
Rev Stan Archie, Member, State Board of Education
David Liechtik, President, State Board of Education
Peter Herschend, Vice Pres., State Board of Education
Chris Nicastro, Commissioner of Education - REPLY
Dr. Bert Schulte, Interim Commissioner of Education
Jim Morris, Director, Public Information

NEW MEXICO (Sent to the below-listed NM recipients on July 7, 2009)
Dr. Veronica Garcia, New Mexico Secretary of Education - REPLY
Catherine Smith, Chair, Public Education Commission
M. Andrew Garrison, Vice Chair, Public Education Commission
Millie Pogana, Secretary, Public Education Commission
Kathryn E. Krivitzky, Member, Public Education Commission
Jeff Carr, Member, Public Education Commission
Carolyn Shearman, Member, Public Education Commission
Eugene E. Grant, Member, Public Education Commission
Vince Bergman, Member, Public Education Commission
Mavis V. Price, Member, Public Education Commission
Carla Lopez, Member, Public Education Commission

NORTH CAROLINA (Sent to the below-listed NC recipients on July 8, 2009)
William C. Harrison, Ed.D., Chairman & Chief Executive Officer, State Board of Education
Paula Hudson Collins, Senior Policy Advisor for Healthy Responsible Students, State Board of Education
Joan Champagne, Paralegal, Member, State Board of Education
Katie Cornetto, Legal Advisor, State Board of Education
Jonathan P. Lindberg, Executive Assistant, State Board of Education
Loretta Peach-Bunch, Executive Assistant, State Board of Education
Chris Minard, Legislative Liason, State Board of Education
Janice Hedgepeth, Executive Assistant, State Board of Education
Kathy Sullivan, Senior Policy Analyst, State Board of Education
Marvin Pittman, Community Liason, State Board of Education
Betsy West, Assistant Executive Director/Director of Operations, State Board of Education

OHIO (Sent to the below-listed OH recipients on July 8, 2009)
John R. Bender, Member, Board of Education
Ann H.Womer Benjamin, Member, Board of Education
Deborah Cain, Member, Board of Education
Michael L. Collins, Member, Board of Education
Dannie Greene, Member, Board of Education
Jeff Hardin, Member, Board of Education
Martha Harris, Member, Board of Education
Susan M. Kaverkos, Member, Board of Education
Robin C. Hovis, Member, Board of Education
Anne E. Jacobs, Member, Board of Education
Kristen E. McKinley, Member, Board of Education
Stephen M. Millett, Member, Board of Education
Mary Rose Oakar, Member, Board of Education
Tammy O'Brien, Member, Board of Education
Dennis M. Reardon, Member, Board of Education
G.R. "Sam" Schloemer, Member, Board of Education
Tracey R. Smith, Member, Board of Education
Carl Wick, Member, Board of Education
Senator Gary Cates
Representative Brian G. Williams

OKLAHOMA (Sent to the below-listed OK recipients on July 10, 2009)
Sandy Garrett, Superintendent
Betsy Mabry, Member, Board of Education
Tim Gilpin, Member, Board of Education
Sue Arnn, Member, Board of Education
Debbie Blue, Member, Board of Education
Gayle Miles-Scott, Member, Board of Education

SOUTH CAROLINA (Sent to the below-listed SC recipients on July 11, 2009)
Kristin Maguire, Member, Board of Education
Tim Moore, Member, Board of Education
Patsy Pye, Member, Board of Education
Bonnie Disney, Member, Board of Education
Hampton Hubbard, Member, Board of Education
Rose Sheheen, Member, Board of Education
Al Simpson, Member, Board of Education
Libby Swad, Member, Board of Education
Charles McKinney, Member, Board of Education
Cindy Clark, Member, Board of Education
Dr. Lyn Norton, Member, Board of Education
Amelia Herlong, Member, Board of Education
Trip DuBard, Member, Board of Education
Phillip Bowers, Member, Board of Education
Dennis Thompson, Jr., Member, Board of Education
Gerrita Postlewait, Member, Board of Education
Dr. J. Britt Blackwell, Member, Board of Education
Dr. Jim Rex, State Superintendent of Education - REPLY

Shelly Kelly, Esquire, Deputy General Counsel, Board of Education

TENNESSEE (Sent to the below-listed TN recipients on July 11, 2009)
Dr. Gary L. Nixon, Executive Director, Tennessee State Board of Education
Richard Rhoda, Executive Director, Tennessee Higher Education Commission
B. Fielding Rolston, Chairman, Board of Educaton
Richard Ray, Member, Board of Educaton
Vernita B. Justice, Member, Board of Educaton
Flavius Barker, Member, Board of Educaton
Carolyn Pearre, Vice Chair, Board of Educaton
Dr. Jean Anne Rogers, Member, Board of Educaton
Jim Ayers, Member, Board of Educaton
Dr. Melvin Wright, Sr., Member, Board of Educaton
Teresa Sloyan, Member, Board of Educaton
Brittni England, Student Member, Board of Educaton

TEXAS (Sent to the below-listed TX recipients on July 15, 2009)
Robert Scott, Commissioner of Education - REPLY
Gail Lowe, Chair, Board of Educaton
Lawrence A Allen, Member, Board of Educaton
Barbara Cargill, Member, Board of Educaton
Ken Mercer, Member, Board of Educaton
Geraldine "Tincy" Miller, Member, Board of Educaton
David Bradley, Member, Board of Educaton
Rick Agosto, Member, Board of Educaton
Rene Nuñez, Member, Board of Educaton
Bob Craig, Member, Board of Educaton
Mavis Knight, Member, Board of Educaton
Mary Helen Berlanga, Member, Board of Educaton
Patricia Hardy, Member, Board of Educaton
Don McLeroy, Member, Board of Educaton

WYOMING (Sent to the below-listed WY recipients on July 14, 2009)
Bill Anthony, Chair, Board of Educaton
Jan Torres, Member, Board of Educaton
Pamela Anderson, Member, Board of Educaton
Sandy Barton, Member, Board of Educaton
Matt Garland, Member, Board of Educaton
Larry McGarvin, Member, Board of Educaton
Dana Mann-Tavegia, Member, Board of Educaton
Jeff Marsh, Member, Board of Educaton
Michelle Sullivan, Member, Board of Educaton
Jim McBride, State Superintendent of Public Instruction
John Shumway, Member, Board of Educaton
Mary Kay HIll, Member, Board of Educaton
Jennifer Duncan, Member, Board of Educaton
Mike Hejtmanek, Member, Board of Educaton


Return to:
Advocacy & Protest
Front Page - www.nospank.net